| Member Comments |
| Member |
Date |
Seema Bagai  | 04/23/09 |
| Wow! I read through this twice to savor every line. Beautiful writing. Excellent work. |
Lori Othouse  | 04/24/09 |
| I love the analogy of the orchestra. And the last paragraph, wow, it gives me chills! Excellent! |
Jan Ackerson  | 04/28/09 |
| I'm a music-lover, so I found this gorgeous! |
Sharon Kane  | 04/28/09 |
A beautiful weaving of the story of redemption with the musical imagery. I love the analogy and I think your choice of specific instruments at various points in the story is very apt.
If I'm allowed to red ink it... I thought the last third got a bit heavy. In the first part you changed the focus at times (talking of grass waving etc,) while towards the end you focused almost entirely on the music. The actions played out on the world stage were only mentioned second. Also you started a lot of sentences with 'but' which became a bit same-ish. So stylistically I felt it floundered a bit.
Having said all that, this is the kind of expression of God's handiwork that I often feel deep within, but invariably fail to put into words! So sincerely, hats off to you! |
Carol Slider  | 04/29/09 |
| I definitely enjoyed the orchestra analogy! As I read it, I was reminded of several works that depict a monumental struggle (Mahler's Symphony No. 2, for example). Well done! |
Joy Stewart  | 04/29/09 |
| This is so beautiful. I read it several times. Wonderful! |
| Beckie Stewart | 04/29/09 |
| This was so beautiful. I could hear it and see it in my mind's eye! |
Lisa Mikitarian  | 04/29/09 |
| I felt as if I were in a concert hall listening to this masterpiece. Beautifully done. |
| Johnna Stein | 04/30/09 |
| Beautiful from the first note (oops) I mean first word to the last. Congrats! |
| Rhonda Schrock | 04/30/09 |
| Very well done - articulate and beautiful. Excellent descriptions from the front row of the concert hall. |
Lollie Hofer  | 04/30/09 |
| I like the flow of this story. It is so powerful and the descriptions were exceptionally strong. It had just the right touch of sentiment without overdoing it. Congratulations on a well-deserved win. (I learned a lot from this piece as well.) |
Betty Castleberry  | 04/30/09 |
| Congratulations on your win for this poetic, beautifully written piece. |
Gerald Shuler  | 05/01/09 |
| Oh, my!!! This is writing at a level I could only dream of accomplishing! Congratulations on your MUCH deserved first place EC. |
Connie Dixon  | 05/01/09 |
| This is amazing. Emotional, creative, inspirational. Loved this a lot. Congratulations. |
Mona Purvis  | 05/02/09 |
| Rachel, this is in a league all its own. Superb! Totally envelops the reader. Mona |
Jim McWhinnie  | 05/03/09 |
Wow and more wow!
I have already tucked this masterpiece in my treasure chest. |
Glynis Becker  | 05/10/09 |
| Beautifully crafted piece and a much deserved first place. Congratulations! |
Margaret Kearley  | 07/01/09 |
| May I add huge congratulations to many more on your well deserved Best of the Best win. I had not read it before today. It is really beautiful and thrills the heart with wonder at what God has (and is) accomplishing. Thankyou so much. |
Dianne Janak  | 07/01/09 |
| This was a masterpiece on so many levels. Thank you so much for this gift to all of us, and now I hope you celebrate the wonderful news of your win. SO well deserved! |
Joanne Sher  | 07/01/09 |
| Oh Rachel. This is incredibly stunning and SO deserving of Best of the Best. Now pick yourself up off the floor. Okay??? ;) |
Lisa Mikitarian  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations to the BEST of the BEST!!!--with such a fantastic story. |
Lynda Schab  | 07/01/09 |
CONGRATULATIONS, RACHEL, on your BOB win! This piece is definitely deserving of it!
I'll be in touch with some interview questions for you.
Wear that crown proudly! :-) |
| Paulette Rogers | 07/01/09 |
"The Composition" is a breathtaking and glorious piece of work. My sincere congratulations to Rachel. Your composition is absolue beautiful. I could read it over and over and over again!
Very creative and artistic!
Sincerely,
Paulette Rogers |
Pat Guy  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations BOB! ; ) Awesome...just so absolutely awesome. You did it girl. Enjoy the clouds! Love, Pat |
Jesus Puppy  | 07/01/09 |
| Way to go Rachel. This piece does in fact stand out, good job, and congrats on winning the crown... BOB. ;-) |
Verna Cole Mitchell  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations, Rachel, BOB. This winning piece grows more beautiful and more inspiring with each succeeding read. |
Chris Surber  | 07/01/09 |
| Very well written. Congratulations! |
Loren Thomas  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations, Rachael. A perfect composition melding both music and words into a memorable story. |
Diana Dart  | 07/01/09 |
| I am shivering... beautiful. Sharp. Soulful. I can't think of the words, cause it just plain rocks (although that seems out of place with the musical style ;) ). Love it. Big, big congrats Rachel on the BoB win. |
Loren Thomas  | 07/01/09 |
| Had to come back and add that this piece reminds me of "Peter and the Wolfe" a story told with musical instruments. Going to the concert to hear it was a Christmas holiday tradition when I was growing up. Something I always looked forward to and learned musical instruments could have voices as well. Thanks for the memory! : ) |
| Sheila Deeth | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations! |
Charla Diehl  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations on this superb entry--not surprised that it earned the BOB award. Wear your crown with a big smile. |
lynn potter  | 07/01/09 |
speachless!
Blessing and honor to the One who has given you the prophetic voice to trumpet a story with such passion and glamour. A truely remarkable piece that should be in print for all who have eyes to see and ears to hear. Glory to God the Father for bringing to us this magnificant writing.
God bless you and increase your gift to His body.
Congratulations! |
| Dorothy Stroup | 07/01/09 |
| WOW! I can hear and visualize the scene you have set, salvation's past, present, and future. You captured salvation's story in a short essay. Quite a feat! Your short sentences carried a punch. Your choice of strong visual words make it easy to see the whole scene in the reader's mind. Well done... |
Allen Stark  | 07/01/09 |
Rachael,
I had just finished reading your poem, "Breath of God" given to me at our last Southwest Iowa Writers Guild meeting when the FaithWriters email came up. Congratulations onwinning the BOB contest.I'm not surprised your piece won, having read your novel and the poem. The beauty in your eyes and in your writing is beholding God the way you do. |
Beth LaBuff  | 07/02/09 |
| Rachel, I could hear your symphony as the story was being played. Your writing is beautiful. I, too, love your last line. Super congratulations on winning Best of the Best! Awesome! |
Verna Mull  | 07/02/09 |
| Congratulations! What an inspiring work, and how great that it has been chosen as the best of the best! God bless you, and keep writing! |
| kurt hardy | 07/02/09 |
Dear Rachel,
What an awsome piece of work.
I only pray that some day I might be able to write what you throw away.
I don't know yet how to critque writing, but I know when something is GREAT.
Thank you for sharing your God given gift.
Kurt
|
| Dan Johnson | 07/03/09 |
This is an amazing piece of literature, certainly creating an experience beyond words. I work in music...and found this to be very powerful! Congrats!
-Dan Johnson
|
Amy Michelle Wiley  | 07/03/09 |
| Oooo, I like this. Very cool. Would love to hear this concert, but you brought it alive to us in your writing. |
Henrietta W. Romman  | 07/05/09 |
Oh dear Rachelle...A million congratulations for this great BOB award! You made my heart to rejoice.....This awesom "musical" masterpiece has honored both Our Lord---and all of us at Faithwriters.
God bless you forever...Amen |
| Laura Godson | 07/08/09 |
| Hi Rachael, I was totally captivated by this piece of writing, wonderfully writen. |
Patricia Herchenroether  | 07/21/09 |
Congratulations, Rachel.
Sorry I'm late with this. I'm breathless. I'm speechless. Oh, my! |
| Linda Buskirk | 07/22/09 |
| The use of an orchestra and its music to highlight God's creation and the victory of salvation is wonderful, and masterfully executed. Thank you for writing a piece that makes both the head and heart worship the majesty, wonder and grace of God! |
Rita Garcia  | 08/13/09 |
Congratulations Rachel! A Magnificent Story! I love the musical journey filled with notes of blessings with every rise and fall of the instruments.
Wishing you continued success with your writing, I loved reading your first three novels--what a treat! |
Janice Fitzpatrick  | 08/19/09 |
| Simply amazing! How beautiful and how deserving of the BOB hon. God bless you and keep being used by the Lord. Congratulations! Praise the Lord.:0) |
Pamela Calhoun  | 09/02/09 |
Wow!
I'm new to writing... you set the bar very very high! Thank you for that.
What a gift you have, thanks for sharing it.
Wow! |
| Roxanne Howard | 09/08/09 |
| I'm in tears. GOD bless you and keep writing. |
| Dawn Ost-Ratliff | 10/10/09 |
I see this writing as a powerful tool to reach others with a deep passion for music. It produces the imagery and a story that is familiar and puts it into the context of the story of our savior. Passion runs deep in those with a love for music, though they often cannot grasp the passion for our Lord. This gives them an understanding of the passion for Jesus.
In all, awesome and inspiring! |
| Oge Maduka | 10/18/09 |
| Beautiful Analogy!Great piece Rachel! |
| Dimple Suit | 10/20/09 |
| Bringing tears to my eyes as I could hear every note in the words you wrote. It is a beautiful symphony filled with hope and love. Thank you so much. |
| Sonia Gray | 10/21/09 |
How exciting and real, Rachel.You made me hear,feel and see the Word come alive. Truly breathtaking to say the least. Well deserving the BoB! Thank you and God bless you abundantly for honoring Him with your gift.
Sonia Gray
|
Carol Penhorwood  | 10/26/09 |
| Absolutely glorious! I'm brand new to faithwriters! What an introduction!!!! |
| valerie chambers | 11/01/09 |
| Wow what else can be said--you said it all |