The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 586 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
02/26/16
Nice testimony of God's care for us. I have a lot of red ink, unfortunately. p. 1 - need a period after job. p. 2 - I was omitted and needs a period. p. 3 - pick, should be pick up and need a comma after offer. p. 4 - need comma after joy, met by this woman; maybe a woman? p. 5 - you are welcome - Phillip had not said anything yet for her to respond to, and contained therein was unnatural dialogue. next to last p. was awkward - sorry for all this. I hope you find it helpful, not critical.
03/02/16
I am happy the MC got such a wonderful job opportunity.

Last week, I received my critique from the judges. They said my dialogue was somewhat stilted. I think at times your characters also use too formal of dialogue. Their suggestion was to read and act out my story.

Keep writing!
This is a nice devotion. You have a good message and I liked how you backed it up with Scripture. It made me stop and thank God for my many blessings I've experienced today.

Your dialog feels a bit stilted and unnatural. I'd urge you to add body language and contractions to help with the flow. For example: Bouncing on the tip of my toes, I nibbled on my lip as I watched the manager shuffle papers on his desk.
Finally, he looked up and smiled. "Congratulations, you've been selected for the job.”
I resisted jumping up and down. Instead, I shook his hand and said, “Thank you; thank you. I can't tell you how much I appreciate this."
Opening the door, the manager pointed to human resources.
“You're welcome. You just need to go pick up your letter and fill out some more paperwork."

I tried to add some body language and make the dialog a little less formal. Just adding contractions can make a huge difference. This may seem petty, but you slightly missed the topic. It was about mail. You focused on a letter. They may seem the same, but there is a subtle difference. Perhaps, she could have received the letter in the mail, and then call the manager. It's not a huge thing, and I might be wrong. Each week, Deb posts in the forums exactly what the topic means and what the judges are looking for. Many people wrote of a letter instead of mail, so it's quite possible, I'm being too literal.

Your message is a great one. God blesses us all the time. Sometimes it's something little, but other times it's something we've been stressing over, but he is always so good to us. Keep writing. I see your gift and am excited to see more of your work.
Yes, God is faithful if we pray and wait on Him, but He doesn't always answer right away. When the answer comes it is so much better than we could have ever dreamed possible.