The Official Writing Challenge
This article has been read 423 times
Member Comments
Member
Date
This piece grabbed my heart and kept me reading. It is beautifully and authentically written. No matter what situation a person has struggled with, many of us have felt the same kind of trauma and the inability to get out of bed and face a new day. (For me, this went on for months after a horrible series of events.) I felt that this piece of writing really connected with me in those experiences and will connect with other readers too. The feeling I had when reading this is, wow, someone understands me. And then the piece, even from the depths of despair, points me to God and reminds me that He is there to help and He cares about me. All of that comes through in the writing and it’s a beautiful balance of raw testimony with trust of God woven in. That is hard to do, and this piece does it well. The piece is so good that I don’t want to nitpick at all. But because a constructive critique was asked for, my only suggestion for improvement would be to proofread carefully because there are typos. Proofreading helps the reader have a smoother experience with no hiccups. And when proofreading, also look for any places where there is repetition in describing actions and trim that. The piece is so engaging that the reader won’t be able to stop reading, even with typos. But with proofreading, it’ll have an even more gripping impact on the reader. Incredible testimony of God’s love. Compelling, authentic and beautifully written. Very engaging. And this piece also accomplishes something that is hard to do, in that it meets people in a very desperate place, yet it leaves the reader feeling hopeful and encouraged and aware of God’s presence and healing love. Awesome!
12/05/20
I echo Janet. Both her critique and her "Awesome!"
Keep up the good work.
12/05/20
This is truly a gripping piece. The authenticity and pain ring out. My suggestion to take this from a good piece to a blowout article is:

tighten the writing. Less passive verb use. Take the reader into the past as if it is the present - because you are reliving it as the present. SHOW the reader your shame, your husband's shock, etc., through vivid dialogue. Pull the reader into the kitchen scene because that is the crux of the story. As an ending, SHOW how you know God forgave you. SHOW that pivotal moment, verse, revelation, etc.

This article shows great promise! Congratulations
This is an incredible, brave testimony. My heart aches for the woman beating herself up even though so many years have passed. I can relate to her more than I care to admit. You introduced a few conflicts right away and they kept me invested in the article to the very end.
Even though this is spectacular, you could knock it up to an even higher level with some minor tweaks. I often learn better by seeing, so here's a quick edit I might suggest:

The vision (I used this because you've used the word dream a few times) catapulted me back thirteen years. As a married woman, dressed in the trouble-making, revealing dress, I relived the disaster that played out in my old kitchen. I knew I had no business wearing the turquoise, too-short dress anywhere, let alone a bar, but it didn't stop me. My drug-addicted husband glared at me as I stumbled. <i>I bet he thinks this is the only time I cheated. Even with all his faults, he doesn't deserve me.</i> (the <i>indicates italics)

This is just a quick example to show how rearranging the words can tighten it up, leaving more room for descriptions, body language, dialog, and thoughts (in italics).
You have an incredible foundation. Your message is perfect for today's world. I'm so sorry you went through all of that pain, but have learned much about myself through your words. The ending brought the story full-circle and left me with hope and a sense of peace. You did an outstanding job and are quite brave. Thank you.
Thanks for sharing this with us. God Bless You.
12/10/20
I love your title -- perfect!

I pray that you will find real joy and peace in your life.
Congratulations on ranking 5th in your level. I just wanted to let you know I really liked this and it was one of my very favorites over all levels this week. Don't ever stop writing. Your words are powerful and do make a difference!
Also, it's nice to see you entering the challenge ago. I've missed you these past three years or so!