Previous Challenge Entry (Level 4 – Masters)
Topic: Talent (01/08/26)
-
TITLE: The Quiet Man | Previous Challenge Entry
By Corinne Smelker
01/15/26 -
LEAVE COMMENT ON ARTICLE
SEND A PRIVATE COMMENT
ADD TO MY FAVORITES
Russo was forty-eight, divorced twice, with a daughter who called him once a month from college in Albany. He wore the same gray suit every day, the one with the frayed cuffs. He liked routine. Routine kept the chaos at arm's length.
That morning, a call came in from the corner of 9th and Carver. A body in an alley behind the old textile mill. Male, late thirties, no ID, single gunshot to the chest. Clean. Professional.
Russo took the call himself. He drove down in the unmarked Ford, radio low, listening to the dispatcher repeat the same details like a tired prayer.
The alley was narrow; bricks blackened from years of exhaust. Uniforms had already taped it off. A rookie named Torres stood by the dumpster, looking green.
“Lieutenant,” Torres said. “Guy's name is Harlan Cole. Wallet was in his back pocket. No cash, no cards missing. Just the body.”
Russo knelt. Cole lay on his back, eyes open to the gray sky. Thin face, cheap haircut, hands calloused but clean. A musician's hands, Russo thought, though he didn't know why.
The M.E. arrived ten minutes later. Doc Ramirez, short, precise, always chewing gum.
“Time of death between midnight and two,” Ramirez said, snapping on gloves. “Single entry, no exit. Small caliber. Looks like he didn't fight.”
Russo nodded. He searched the pockets again. Found a folded piece of paper, yellowed, with a phone number scrawled in pencil. And a small key, the kind that opens a locker.
Back at the precinct, Russo ran the number. It belonged to a church on the edge of the district—St. Michael's, the one with the soup kitchen that never turned anyone away. The pastor was a man named Father Elias, sixty-something, voice like gravel over water.
“Yeah, Harlan came here,” Elias said when Russo showed up at the rectory door. “Not for services. For the basement.”
“Basement?”
“Piano down there. Old upright. Harlan would come in after hours, play. Nobody bothered him. Said it kept him steady.”
Russo followed the priest down narrow stairs. The basement smelled of damp concrete and old hymnals. The piano sat against the wall, keys yellowed, bench worn smooth.
“He played every night for three years,” Elias said. “Never asked for anything. Just sat and played. Bach, mostly. Sometimes hymns when he thought no one was listening. Beautiful. Like the music was the only thing holding him together.”
Russo touched a key. Middle C. It rang clear.
“Talented?” Russo asked.
“More than that. Gifted. He could have played anywhere. Carnegie Hall. But he stayed here. Said the city noise drowned out the bad thoughts.”
Russo looked at the piano. Then at the priest. “He ever talk about why he stopped?”
Elias shook his head. “Last week he said he was done. Said the music had done what it was supposed to do. Helped him forgive himself. Helped him forgive someone else. I asked what. He just smiled and said, ‘Enough.’”
Russo went back to the squad room. Ran Cole's name through the system again. Found it: juvenile record, sealed. Armed robbery at seventeen. Served time. Clean since.
The bullet matched a case from six months earlier, a dealer found in the river. No witnesses. No leads.
Russo sat at his desk, stared at the key. Thought about the piano in the basement, the hands that had played it, the man who had walked away from something bigger than himself.
He closed the file.
Later, on his way home, he stopped at St. Michael's. The church was empty. He went down to the basement anyway. Sat on the bench. Played nothing. Just listened to the silence.
Somewhere in the city, a note lingered. Not loud. Not showy. Just there.
Waiting for the next person who needed it.
The opinions expressed by authors may not necessarily reflect the opinion of FaithWriters.com.
Accept Jesus as Your Lord and Savior Right Now - CLICK HERE
JOIN US at FaithWriters for Free. Grow as a Writer and Spread the Gospel.
