| Member Comments |
| Member |
Date |
| Ann Renae Hair | 02/14/08 |
| I loved this POV from the servant's perspective. Very authentic, right down to her dumping the water out the window! You captured the scene and revealed it in details for us to see and feel. Excellent. |
| Sally Hanan | 02/14/08 |
| You captured so much with this short story, especially managing to capture silence--so hard to do when writing. Lovely work! |
Verna Cole Mitchell  | 02/15/08 |
| This story is so realistic as seen through the eyes of the servant. I loved it. |
| Patty Wysong | 02/17/08 |
| The servant girl's POV adds so much to this and lets us see more of the event. All the tiny details add to the feel, not just build a setting. Great job. |
Laury Hubrich  | 02/17/08 |
What a great job bringing another piece of Biblical history to life! Bravo!
Laury |
Sharlyn Guthrie  | 02/18/08 |
| Very very good! I just studied this passage for my Sunday school class (that was cancelled due to weather!). I love the character development and the POV. The ending seemed a little abrupt; but alas, the word count! Your writing is seamless, and brings this story to life. |
| LauraLee Shaw | 02/18/08 |
| This was very engaging. I think the ending you chose is my favorite. It is one of my fav verses in the Bible, and it concluded the piece perfectly. |
Betty Castleberry  | 02/18/08 |
| You've done it again, Missy Joanne. You have the ability to put the reader right in the heart of the scene. This was very well done. |
Yvonne Blake  | 02/18/08 |
I like the way you make familiar stories seem new again, by looking at them from a different angle.
Well done! |
| Debbie Wistrom | 02/18/08 |
| I was looking forward to another Bible story from you and was not disappointed. So loved the thoughts of Rikva. I like getting to know the lesser characters, through you. |
| william price | 02/18/08 |
| Very good job, Jo-anne. The pace was slow and deliberate, building up to the ending. Excellent writing and description and characters. God bless. |
| Leigh MacKelvey | 02/18/08 |
I always loved this story and it was retold from a different perspective and creatively by this wonderful author!
( Joanne!)
Keep on the these and where's that book? |
| Paula Titus | 02/18/08 |
| Loved this! You may know I try my hand at Bible stories often, but none can compare to the way you give us new and fresh perspectives. |
Debbie Roome  | 02/18/08 |
| Captivating writing. Very good. |
LaNaye Perkins  | 02/18/08 |
| Another excellent story based on the Bible. I love the way you tell these stories my friend. Great Job! |
Rita Garcia  | 02/18/08 |
| Another story brought to life with a whole new spin! LOVE IT! |
Jan Ackerson  | 02/19/08 |
| I love the way you capture a moment in time, in an economy of words, but with such richness! |
| Christine Dunn | 02/19/08 |
| I really like how you brought this story to life, and the servant girl's reaction to it all. Well done. |
Lynda Schultz  | 02/19/08 |
| Here's a woman who missed the point entirely. Nice job, Joanne, as usual. |
Joy Stewart  | 02/19/08 |
| Love the way you draw your reader into Bible stories. You feel the characters to be "real" people while reminding us of the bibical message. Fantastic! |
Shelley Ledfors  | 02/20/08 |
| Oh, my! In my initial "brainstorming" for this topic I had thought of Michal / David. I am so glad I didn't choose it. I could not have come close to this wonderful piece. Once again, you have brought a Bible story alive! |
Beth LaBuff  | 02/20/08 |
| I loved reading this story through Rivka's eyes. What a beautiful character you've created with her. You've brought this Bible story to life for us. This is so expertly and beautfully crafted! |
Pam Carlson-Hetland  | 02/20/08 |
| Absolutely wonderful job bringing this biblical account to life. Loved the POV. Masterfully written. Great job. |
S Harricharan  | 02/20/08 |
| Wow, to see this glimpse of life from one verse! I applaud your eyes to see into the story there. You made this come alive and more real, seeing it from this POV, it was a different twist. I liked it. Great writing ^_^ |
Peter Stone  | 02/20/08 |
| Lovely rendition of one of the most tragic stories in the Bible. |
| Henry Clemmons | 02/21/08 |
| I can see why you have received so many comments. Besides being a sweet soul you can deliver a message like a true master. Very inspirational. |
Glynis Becker  | 02/24/08 |
| Yes, Joanne, I can see you making a longer (and wonderful) novel out of this! |
| Mark Frank | 10/01/09 |
| Great story...Amen. |