Home Read What's New Join
My Account Login

Read Our Devotional             2016 Opportunities to be Published             Detailed Navigation

The HOME for Christian writers! The Home for Christian Writers!
The Official Writing Challenge



how it works
submission rules
guidelines for
choosing a level


submit your entry
read current entries
read past entries
challenge winners

Our Daily Devotional HERE
Place it on your site or
receive it daily by email.



how it works   Submit

Previous Challenge Entry (Level 2 – Intermediate)
Topic: The Critique/Review (for writers) (05/06/10)

TITLE: The Eighteenth Critique of KittyMarie
By Caitlyn Meissner


“Well, I finally did it,” I said, walking into the kitchen where my two roommates sat eating breakfast.

“Did what?” Tracy asked, looking up from her newspaper. Catherine continued sipping her coffee.

“I joined that online writer’s forum I’ve been telling you about.”

“Jen, that’s great!” Tracy said, applauding.

I took a bow, scooped Tracy’s cat, Horace, off of my chair, and sat down. “From now on,” I said, stroking Horace, “the world will finally have the chance to read the stories of Jennifer Anne Dawes.”

Catherine rolled her eyes. “No offense, Jen,” she said, “but aren’t you still a beginning writer? What makes you think anyone will want to read YOUR stories? I know I hate reading anything that isn’t extremely well-written.”

“Every great writer has to start somewhere,” I retorted. “I’m sure the people on the forum understand that.”

“They’ll probably give you lots of advice,” Tracy added.

“Well, whatever happens,” Catherine replied, smiling, “never give up on your dream. I’m sure you’ll be an author some day.”

After work that evening I uploaded my first chapter onto the forum, and the next day I waited eagerly for a critique.


“It might take a little longer than one day before somebody notices you,” Tracy assured me.

But at the end of two weeks, nobody had even looked at my story. And as other stories received critiques, it bothered me to know that I was the only one left out.

“I guess you were right all along,” I told Catherine the next morning at breakfast. “I’ve written the most unpopular story on the planet. Nobody wants to read it.”

“I’ll read it,” Tracy said, setting aside her favorite book on cats. “I always wanted to, and maybe I can tell you what went wrong.”

Encouraged, I pulled Tracy over to my computer, opened the file, and showed her my story.

Her face fell. “Thirty-nine pages?” she gasped. “Single-spaced? Jen, NOBODY has time to critique a thirty-nine page chapter. No wonder you’ve had problems! How about I just take a look at the first four pages?”

I nodded, and slunk back into the kitchen. “Even Tracy doesn’t want to read it,” I informed Catherine, taking a seat across from her and burying my head in my hands.

“Don’t give up, Jen,” Catherine said, concerned. “Never give up on your dream.”

“Why not, if nobody else cares?” I asked.

That evening I decided to check the forum one last time. Saying a quick prayer, I clicked on the critiquing board, and froze.

But only for a moment.

“Tracy!” I yelled. “Catherine! Come see THIS!”

“What?” Tracy asked, stumbling into my room in her pink kitten pajama bottoms.

“Someone critiqued my story!” I cried, jumping up and doing my happy dance.

“No way,” Catherine said, running in and taking a look. “That’s a real critique all right. It has everything: changes, suggestions, and praise.”

“But who’s KittyMarie?” Tracy asked, looking at the name of my benefactor.

“I don’t know,” I admitted. “Check her profile, Catherine.”

But there was no information, no picture, nothing. The whole profile was blank.

“How exciting!” Tracy said. “A mysterious critiquer.”

It WAS exciting. Over the next few weeks, every time I uploaded a new chapter, KittyMarie was there to read it. Soon I began receiving critiques from CShell, dramaqueen, and Ladybug55, though none could compare to KittyMarie. She pointed out my faults without sounding rude, and she always had a lot of good suggestions.

How excited I was when I finally uploaded my seventeenth and final chapter for KittyMarie to read. But when I looked at her critique, all she said was,

“Congratulations! Never give up on your dream.”

“Catherine!” I yelled, storming into her bedroom. “Are you KittyMarie?”

“What?” she asked, peering at me over her magazine.

Her eyes gave her away.

“Didn’t you tell me once that your dad used to call you ‘Kitty’?”


“What about ‘Marie’?”

“My middle name,” she admitted.

“Why did you do it?” I asked.

Catherine shrugged. “It’s easy to tell people to ‘never give up’,” she said, “but you showed me that it’s more important to help people fulfill their dreams. I just wanted you to see that you ARE a great writer, Jen. Consider that your own personal critique.”

“And you are a great friend,” I replied, hugging her. “So, does that mean you’ll keep on critiquing?”

“Nope,” Catherine said, laughing. “I think that was my eighteenth, and final, critique.”

The opinions expressed by authors may not necessarily reflect the opinion of FaithWriters.com.
If you died today, are you absolutely certain that you would go to heaven? You can be right now. CLICK HERE

JOIN US at FaithWriters for Free. Grow as a Writer and Spread the Gospel.

This article has been read 570 times
Member Comments
Member Date
AnneRene' Capp05/13/10
Very unique, very entertaining and just darn right cute! Really enjoyed your creativity on this.

I'm encouraging level 1 and level 2 comrades to join me in the free forum classes under "writing". Jan and Ann offer grammar and writing basics for us and it's absolutely great!
Mildred Sheldon05/13/10
Thank you so much. This was as cute and entertaining as ever. I really liked this.
Virgil Youngblood 05/14/10
Well written with a good ending and title. This was fun to read.
Susan Montaperto05/14/10
Very enjoyable read. Thank you. I really liked the ending.
Joanna Stricker05/17/10
Very original, I liked the sneakiness of the MC's friend, and that she stopped her notes once the mystery was gone--obviously because her job was through. What a good picture of friendship!
Amanda Brogan05/17/10
Good title for another well-written entry!

Interesting how Catherine turned out to be the one who encouraged and believed in Jen the most when at first she seemed almost inconsiderate of her writing dream. I almost thought that Tracy was the mysterious critiquer because of her obvious love for cats. :D

I think this is great for the topic.
Maria Egilsson05/17/10
Caitlyn, good job. liked the ending as well.
Lyn Churchyard05/18/10

Love the title for starters. Quite a unique take on the topic. As writers, we all need friends like Tracy and Catherine. Oh, hang on... we do-right here at Faithwriters :-)

I only picked up on one tiny thing, I think there should have been an extra dash between nine and page in thirty-nine-page chapter

This was a good, smooth flowing read, well done!
Amanda Brogan05/20/10
Yay Caity! How did I know you'd be getting first place? ;) See you in Advanced!
Dusti (Bramlage) Zarse05/21/10
I loved this! And I loved what a great friend KittyMarie was! Congratulations. You deserve it.

I think, just like Jen, we all want to top a best-seller list and have the world adore our writing, but sometimes, while the rest of the world ignores what we've written, we can still make a difference for one person. And sometimes that's more important. A few years ago, I wrote a book I poured my heart into. I tried to get it published, but nobody wanted it. I even had an agent helping me. Still no go. Frustrated, I let my boyfriend read it and asked for his honest opinion. His honest opinion? He read it through twice before giving it back (and saved a copy on his computer). It changed his life. He's my husband now, and when I get discouraged, he never stops reminding me that my writing changed his life. Sometimes, that one person is more valuable than the thousands who pull it off a bookstore shelf. Like Jen, don't get discouraged if it feels like no one cares about your writing. God always does. And He'll use it in ways you can't imagine. Keep up the great work!