Home Read What's New Join
My Account Login

Read Our Devotional             2016 Opportunities to be Published             Detailed Navigation

The HOME for Christian writers! The Home for Christian Writers!
The Official Writing Challenge



how it works
submission rules
guidelines for
choosing a level


submit your entry
read current entries
read past entries
challenge winners

Our Daily Devotional HERE
Place it on your site or
receive it daily by email.



how it works   Submit

Previous Challenge Entry (Level 1 – Beginner)
Topic: The Critique/Review (for writers) (05/06/10)

TITLE: The Critique (i)
By veronica cressey


I am going to go out on a limb here and ask who exactly has the right to critique another's work? Does it mean you have letters after your name? Are you a Master in Philosophy, Poetry,Theology, Prose? Even if you are, {and I am not being sarcastic,}do you really know the language of the heart?
You may have a young person bleeding, through poetry,her/his heartfelt sadness. On the other hand, you may read another person who has, {in their world} made it, through publishing their novel.
But who are we, really, to critique another writer?
I have a problem here. Are we, as readers right to point out a typing error?Do we have the right to say; oh, your plot is totally wrong? Or your grammer needs a tweak in the right direction? How much criticism does the beginner need to take on board before he/she decides to say, to hell with this idea?
Before I ever critique a piece of work on Faithwriters, I read behind the lines of their article. I can usually perceive where the writer is at his/her stage of development, and I will usually critique along that line.
My brother has spent his entire adult life studying drama, writing plays,acting, singing, composing. God Bless him and his art!
However, when I showed him my art of composing music or writing lyrics, he seemed only too happy to tell me where I was going wrong! I was a mere beginner and I can honestly say, he stopped me in my tracks!'
This is the danger of being a little too critical in analyzing another's art.
For all you writers, poets, novelists on Faithwriters, let me assure you to let youselves flow in your ability to put pen to paper and I wish you the very best in your endeavours.

The opinions expressed by authors may not necessarily reflect the opinion of FaithWriters.com.
If you died today, are you absolutely certain that you would go to heaven? You can be right now. CLICK HERE

JOIN US at FaithWriters for Free. Grow as a Writer and Spread the Gospel.

This article has been read 691 times
Member Comments
Member Date
AnneRene' Capp05/13/10
It is true, some critiques are harsh and I too find those critiques stiff, unfeeling and unwarranted.

However...Done with love, it is a nurturing tool to keep us on a path of success and for me, am convicted to help and not turn the other way in comfort (playing it safe)and allow any to flounder.

Harsh criticism hurts and we've all been there, so please don't throw in the towel, as you did an EXCELLENT job conveying your heart and the heart of so many others!
Sara Harricharan 05/13/10
Ah, what a lovely transparent piece! One main reason I love Faithwriters is because of the wonderful support and encouragement from other writers--presented in a way that doesn't make me wish I could melt into the floor. A great reminder to encourage new writers--good job!
Sarah Morrison05/13/10
I agree with you to a point. If a piece has been written purely to pour out one's heart, then critique
Sarah Morrison05/13/10
I agree with you to a point. If a piece has been written purely to pour out one's heart, then critique is unnecessary. To critique such a piece of writing, would be like critiquing a friend's story as she sat to tell me of her day or of something she's going through.

However, if one is writing for publishing purposes, then the critique process has a place, even a necessary place. Grammar, spelling, even ideas often need tweaking, and sometimes a second pair of eyes can help us see what needs tweaked, just as its easier to hang a picture with someone standing by to tell us whether or not it's straight. Don't throw out the critique. Just learn when to use it.
Maria Kana Santos05/14/10
I admire your courage in opening up your heart to us. But before you did, the Lord knew all about it. And He is faithful to set you in the hallow of his hand as He helps you minister through your writing for His honour.
Be encouraged, fellow writer.
Timothy Klingerman05/14/10
Your original question was, "who has a right to critique?" I think the answer is found in your piece. A critique is itself a piece of literature, so treat it the same way you want your work treated. Look for the heart of the person behind the critique, and know that they would not have bothered to write it for you if tey did not care for you and your work. Thanks for challenging us all with this piece.
Maria Egilsson05/14/10
Your writing made me think of this quote from Salinger:

“An artist's only concern is to shoot for some kind of perfection, and on his own terms, not anyone else's.” J D Salinger (American Novelist and short story Writer)

More food for thought!
Mildred Sheldon05/14/10
Short, direct and to the point. You my friend have written what many of us feel but lack words to express it. You did a fantastic job in doing just that, but sometimes a little critique given in love helps us grow beyond our wildest imaginations. Never be discouraged and never permit anyong steal your dreams. God gave each of us a dream. Pursue it and give God the glory.