| Member Comments |
| Member |
Date |
Lynda Schultz  | 01/15/09 |
| These lines are particularly wonderful: "A country of wonderfully insane contradictions. A place where we foolishly waste fortunes on South American worms while at the same time give even more to those who only dream of attempting something so bold. A place where the greatest of intentions are held in place by the slimmest of hopes. A place where a few are even willing to die to ensure others the right to ridicule those who died for them." Very good. |
Trina Courtenay  | 01/16/09 |
Makes one think...
Blessings on your writing. |
Joanne Sher  | 01/17/09 |
| Incredible descriptions, and I especially like the last couple paragraphs. Beautiful. |
Verna Cole Mitchell  | 01/17/09 |
| You introduced a real, wonderful American character to us. |
Angela M. Baker-Bridge  | 01/19/09 |
| An interesting character that probably exists somewhere in this great land. |
Jan Ackerson  | 01/20/09 |
| Love the descriptions of the "inner sanctum", and the quirky character you created. |
Michele Roach  | 01/22/09 |
| This was superb.Congrats on the biggest of wins...you so deserved it. |
Sheri Gordon  | 01/22/09 |
| Congratulations on your 1st place. This is beautifully written. Clark, and your MC, are great Americans. |
Glynis Becker  | 01/22/09 |
| Congratulations on a wonderful entry! Beautifully descriptive and deeply touching. |
Lisa Mikitarian  | 01/22/09 |
| What a fabulous story and take on the topic. Congratulations on your first place--well deserved. |
| Sally Hanan | 01/22/09 |
| An excellent piece with beautifully written insight. |
| Paula Titus | 01/22/09 |
| Congratulations Tim! I particularly enjoyed the last paragraph- powerful writing. |
Myrna Noyes  | 01/23/09 |
| Congratulations on your top-flight entry! The characters were delightfully drawn, the scene wonderfully described! Excellent writing and worthy of first place honor! :) |
Mona Purvis  | 01/23/09 |
Clark Dobbs was so well "shared" with the reader that I think I know him.
You did a sophisticated approach using common man. Made me think. Congrats on winning. |
Charla Diehl  | 01/23/09 |
| This is a great story with a powerful message. Your descriptive writing made every sentence come alive for me--especially the MC. Your final paragraph wrapped this up nicely. Congrats on a well deserved win. |
Debbie OConnor  | 01/26/09 |
| Wow! Congratulations, I can certainly understand why this piece took 1st. I don't have to read another entry to get that. This is the perfect analogy of our wonderful, conflicted, generous, yet slightly "touched" country. God bless you for writing it! :) |
| Ashley Isaacson | 01/28/09 |
| I can see why this entry placed first. Though I haven't read the competition, I would have given it high markings as well--such excellent characterization in so short of space. I enjoyed the actual writing as well, like the phrasing: "Clark’s house was a two room affair sitting on stilts in the middle of his little catfish pond". It made me chuckle myself, sharing in the amusement of the narrator. I suppose you need more critiques than praises, but I can't offer that on this one. |
| Claudette Wood | 04/28/09 |
| good stuff, Tim. very good. |
Joanne Sher  | 07/01/09 |
| Sooooo good Tim. SO glad I had a reason to read this again - and CONGRATULATIONS on third place in BoB! |
Lisa Mikitarian  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations Tim on your huge win with a fantastic story!!!! |
Lynda Schab  | 07/01/09 |
| CONGRATULATIONS, TIM! Your entry is wonderful and so deserving of a place in the top 3. :-) |
Verna Cole Mitchell  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations, Tim, on being in the top three for BOB. The character you created so skillfully deserved a winning place. |
Loren Thomas  | 07/01/09 |
| Congratulations, Tim. Reading this one has little doubt as to your ability to write and develop memorable characters that leave an imprint on our hearts and minds. |
| Sheila Deeth | 07/01/09 |
| That's neat. Thought-provoking, draws the reader in to see something different and see through different eyes. Congratulations. |
| Kate Grey | 07/01/09 |
Really cool analogy, Tim. And lots of colorful and interesting words. Congrats on your BOB placing.
~SisJ |
Karlene Jacobsen  | 07/02/09 |
Tim, Tim, Tim; excellent work. The descriptions in here are so vivid.
Congrats on 3rd place BoB! |
Beth LaBuff  | 07/02/09 |
| I knew a man like this. This so aptly gets to "bottom line". Congrats, Tim, on the high honor you received with this story! |
Verna Mull  | 07/02/09 |
| What a neat story. It should teach each of us a lesson on judging another. Everyone here has been created by our God, and for a purpose. You certainly brought that thought out. Bless you, and, may we all learn the lesson well! |
Genia Gilbert  | 07/05/09 |
| Congratulations on your BOB award! It is well deserved, and speaks so truly of our USA. With all its faults, we're so blessed to be here. |
| Brenda Shipman | 10/04/09 |
| Loved reading this! What a fine example of how an ordinary encounter with an extraordinary person can turn into a story that carries so much inspiration. Congratulations on your well-deserved win! |
| Marilyn Schnepp | 10/07/09 |
| Absolutely brilliant! A read that not only fascinated, educated, touched me and almost moved me to tears with the simplicity of the story. Written like a Pro - and well worth your Win. (Haven't read the 1st and 2nd winners as of yet - but when I do...I may even come back to tell you I liked yours best! Congratulations! Better late than never! You gave me a new look at our Motherland...and at a time I needed it badly. Thanks! Great job! |
Carol Penhorwood  | 10/26/09 |
| Very poignant! What characterization! Can't even imagine any criticisms. Great writing!! |